Right now all i have is the black velvet velvetine and though its definitely not my favourite liquid lipstick, its better than these knockoffs :S
-The colours are very wrong, especially Faded
-Smell is really synthetic and floral-y. Pretty off-putting.
-Dries matte quickly
-Very hard to remove (long lasting)
|Black Velvet is Authentic, The rest are fake.|
|Far left is authentic. All the rest are fake.|
|Top to Bottom:|
I would recommend Nyx's lingerie line instead if you're on a budget. They're $9, a lot less drying and excellent colours. If you can afford to go higher, OFRA and Gerard cosmetics are my two top faves atm, in terms of formula and colour.
Have you bought the fake ones? Have you tried both?